If you can't view the message, please click here.

LLB Bulletin Header
LLB Bulletin #11/2023 6 November 2023

CASE HIGHLIGHTS

CHEN KIM YAN v. PICO INTERNATIONAL (M) SDN BHD
INDUSTRIAL COURT, KUALA LUMPUR
SYED NOH SAID NAZIR
AWARD NO. 1808 OF 2023 [CASE NO: 21-4-544-22]
22 AUGUST 2023

Abstract – The COVID-19 pandemic, which impacted businesses all across the globe, did not give an employer a carte blanche to retrench their employees under the guise of financial hardship. To do so would be an affront to the relationship between an employer and an employee which is built on trust and confidence. Like the employers, the employees too are anxious of the uncertainties caused by the pandemic. The company must prove, on the balance of probabilities, bona fide redundancy as a result of a dire straits of financial situation caused by the pandemic.

LABOUR LAW: Dismissal - Retrenchment - Redundancy - Employer retrenched employee on grounds of redundancy - Company allegedly facing financial hardship due to COVID-19 pandemic and Movement Control Order - Employee's position consolidated with another position and was allegedly no longer available in company - Whether retrenchment with just cause or excuse - Whether there was redundancy - Whether evidence supported allegations of financial hardship submitted by company

ANG BEE HOON v. BE-P PHARMACY SDN BHD
INDUSTRIAL COURT, KUALA LUMPUR
ESWARY MAREE
AWARD NO. 1854 OF 2023 [CASE NO: 14-4-2206-19]
4 SEPTEMBER 2023

Abstract – A harmonious environment in a workplace is vital in order to maintain the mental well-being of employees. The use of abusive language and threatening words creates an unhealthy and toxic environment and is, ultimately, an all subversive of discipline that warrants nothing less than the punishment of dismissal.

LABOUR LAW: Employment - Dismissal - Gross misconduct and severe breaches of appointment terms - Employee screamed at and scolded staff in office and in public - Whether misconducts established - Whether misconducts constituted just cause or excuse for dismissal

LABOUR LAW: Employment - Dismissal - Gross misconduct and severe breaches of appointment terms - Employee shouted and rioted violently at company's panel clinic when medical chits were not provided to her - Employee begged other patients at clinic to pay off medical bill - Employee had to be escorted out of clinic by police - Whether misconduct established - Whether misconduct constituted just cause or excuse for dismissal

LABOUR LAW: Employment - Dismissal - Gross misconduct and severe breaches of appointment terms - Employee away from office and uncontactable for one week without approval and without providing supporting documents - Whether misconduct established - Whether misconduct constituted just cause or excuse for dismissal

LABOUR LAW: Employment - Dismissal - Performance - Employee neglected performance of duties - Whether misconduct established - Whether misconduct constituted just cause or excuse for dismissal

LATEST CASES (ILR Issue 10 of 2023)

Award Parties Citation Links
  CIMB Bank Bhd v. Ahmad Suhairi Mat Ali & Anor
[Civil Appeal No: P-01(A)-403-07-2021]
[2023] 4 ILR 1 cljlaw
labourlaw
  Sean Su Wei Jiang v. Mahkamah Perusahaan Malaysia & Anor
[Judicial Review No: WA-25-383-05-2022]
[2023] 4 ILR 69 cljlaw
labourlaw
  Yong Pui Yee v. Mahkamah Perusahaan Malaysia & Anor
[Judicial Review No: WA-25-143-04-2021]
[2023] 4 ILR 88 cljlaw
labourlaw
  1623/2023 Wong Thai Ping v. MRCB Builders Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 6(15)(6)-4-1990-21]
[2023] 4 ILR 104 cljlaw
labourlaw
1808/2023 Chen Kim Yan v. Pico International (M) Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 21-4-544-22]
[2023] 4 ILR 130 cljlaw
labourlaw
1809/2023 Chong Sin Lan v. Pico International (M) Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 21-4-545-22]
[2023] 4 ILR 152 cljlaw
labourlaw
1831/2023 Ridzuan Yahya v. Air Asia X Bhd
[Case No: 22/4-13-21]
[2023] 4 ILR 175 cljlaw
labourlaw
1852/2023 Stephen Yeap Ban Eng v. Galeri Tropika Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 5/4-1527/21]
[2023] 4 ILR 197 cljlaw
labourlaw
1854/2023 Ang Bee Hoon v. BE-P Pharmacy Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 14-4-2206-19]
[2023] 4 ILR 204 cljlaw
labourlaw
1897/2023 All Malayan Estates Staff Union v. Ladang Rakyat Terengganu Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 20(4)-3-638-21]
[2023] 4 ILR 221 cljlaw
labourlaw
1924/2023 Shahrul Faeizal Abd Aziz v. UBF Maintenance Sdn Bhd
[Case No: 4-4-995-22]
[2023] 4 ILR 234 cljlaw
labourlaw

SUBJECT INDEX

APPEAL/REVIEW UPDATES

  1. CIMB Bank Bhd v. Ahmad Suhairi Mat Ali & Anor [2023] 4 ILR 1 (CA) affirming High Court decision of Ahmad Suhairi Mat Ali v. CIMB Bank Bhd [2021] 1 LNS 1572

  2. Sean Su Wei Jiang v. Mahkamah Perusahaan [2023] 4 ILR 69 (HC) affirming Industrial Court Award of Sean Su Wei Jiang v. PM Link Sdn Bhd [2022] 2 LNS 0531

  3. Yong Pui Yee v. Mahkamah Perusahaan Malaysia & Anor [2023] 4 ILR 88 (HC) affirming Industrial Court Awards of Yong Pui Yee v. CIMB Investment Bank Berhad [2021] 3 ILR 216 and Yong Pui Yee v. PricewaterhouseCoopers [2021] 1 ILR 387



Annual   Publish   LLB Blog
         
Hourly   Submit   Training

CLJ WEBSITES

(Available with separate subscription plan)

FOLLOW US

Facebook Twitter Instagram

Feedback
Copyright © 2023 MYLAWBOX Sdn Bhd To unsubscribe click here